Below is a summary of the full article. Click here for the full version or go back to LFC Live.net
Depending on your content consumption habits, it made for a great watch or listen.
Both provided arguments over who is to blame - if anybody - for a situation that seems set to end with Alexander-Arnold walking away from his boyhood club after 20 years of sterling service and all for the princely sum of absolutely nothing at all.
But one thing Neville said stuck in the craw - and it was to do with the 26-year-old's popularity compared to other homegrown Reds heroes like Steven Gerrard, Robbie Fowler and Carragher himself.
As a former homegrown right-back himself, Neville should know better.
Theo Squires
For Gary Neville to suggest Trent Alexander-Arnold is not held in the same regard as some of Liverpool's other homegrown heroes is just rubbish.
To quote Jamie Carragher, 'no-one grows up wanting to be a Gary Neville'.
Indeed, if he thinks Liverpool fans don't hold Trent Alexander-Arnold in high esteem then he only needs to see the response to rumours this week that a move to Real Madrid has been agreed.
The hostility shown towards Liverpool's vice-captain only goes to show how highly he is regarded by those who attend Anfield each week.
That's true of all homegrown product to come through Liverpool's academy.
But it has been Liverpool fans who have backed Trent when he has been misunderstood by the wider nation, misused by England and, ironically, criticised each week by Neville and his old Manchester United team-mates despite being a key player in a team that has won everything since he debuted in 2017.
So for Neville to say otherwise shows his ignorance.
Check out his pre-season predictions every single season or simply wait until August for him to do it all again.
Paul Wheelock
Of all the rebuttals Jamie Carragher made to Gary Neville, this was the most pertinent: "You don’t live in Liverpool, you don’t know Liverpool."
Because if Gary Neville did, he would know he is wrong.
For more news relating to Manchester United, visit our sister site MUFC Live.